Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream

Navigation
sisley-black-rose-skin-infusion-cream-opyo-hero

Overall Score

    8

    Ingredient Analysis

    7

    Clinical Testing

    8

    Sensory Attributes

    8

    Price and Value Analysis

Best For

Considerations

Our Verdict

Testing

8

Ingredient Analysis


Ingredients Research: No Irritants Found

First things first: the star of the show. The Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream gets its name from the Rosa Damascena Flower Water that sits at the top of its ingredient list. This antioxidant-rich botanical extract is known for its anti-aging properties, and has been used for centuries to help soothe and nourish the skin.

But as any rose enthusiast knows, not all rose extracts are created equal. And while the Rosa Damascena Flower Water in this cream is certainly a lovely addition, it’s hard to say just how much of an impact it’s actually having on the skin. After all, it’s just one ingredient among many.

Speaking of which, let’s take a look at some of the other key players in this cream’s ingredient lineup. There’s glycerin, a tried-and-true moisturizer that helps to attract and retain moisture in the skin. There’s also shea butter, a rich emollient that helps to soften and smooth the skin’s surface.

But here’s where things start to get a little murky. One of the top ingredients in the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream is dimethicone, a type of silicone that’s commonly used in skincare products to help create a smooth, silky texture. And while dimethicone is generally considered safe for use in skincare, some people find that it can be irritating or clogging to their skin.

And then there’s the mysterious “Black Rose Extract” that’s listed among the cream’s ingredients. Despite my best efforts, I couldn’t find much information on what exactly this extract is, or what benefits it’s supposed to provide for the skin. It’s not rated for safety on any of the databases I checked, which makes me a little wary.

But overall, the ingredient list for the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream is relatively short and sweet. Most of the ingredients are rated as low risk for irritation or other adverse effects, which is always a good sign. And the inclusion of nourishing botanicals like rose water and shea butter is certainly appealing for those looking for a luxurious, pampering skincare experience.

IngredientKey FunctionsSafety Rating
Rosa Damascena Flower WaterAntioxidant, Anti-AgingLow Risk
GlycerinMoisturizerLow Risk
Shea ButterEmollientLow Risk
DimethiconeCleansingLow Risk
Black Rose ExtractUnknownUnrated

pH Test: Normal

As any skincare aficionado worth their weight in serums knows, pH is everything when it comes to keeping your complexion happy and healthy. After all, our skin has a delicate balance to maintain, and using products that are too acidic or too alkaline can throw that balance way out of whack.

So, when I got my hands on a jar of Sisley’s Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream, the first thing I did was whip out my trusty pH strips and put this luxurious moisturizer to the test.

The process was simple enough. I squeezed a small dollop of the cream onto a pH strip, and watched with bated breath as the color began to change. Would it veer into the dangerous territory of too acidic or too alkaline, or would it land somewhere in the goldilocks zone of just right?

After a few seconds, the verdict was in. The Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream clocked in at a pH of 5.0 – slightly acidic, but still well within the ideal range for healthy skin.

But what does this mean, exactly? Well, let’s take a closer look at the key ingredients in this cream to find out.

First up, we have rose water – a gentle, hydrating ingredient that’s known for its soothing properties. Rose water is naturally slightly acidic, with a pH that hovers around 5.0. So far, so good.

Next, there’s glycerin – a humectant that helps to attract and retain moisture in the skin. Like rose water, glycerin is also slightly acidic, with a pH that typically falls between 4.5 and 5.5.

But then we have shea butter and dimethicone – two ingredients that are known for their neutral pH. Shea butter is a rich, nourishing emollient that helps to soften and smooth the skin, while dimethicone is a silicone-based ingredient that helps to create a protective barrier on the skin’s surface.

When you put all of these ingredients together, you get a cream with a slightly acidic to neutral pH – which is exactly what we want for healthy, balanced skin.

Just because a product has a pH that falls within the ideal range, doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to work wonders for your skin. There are a lot of other factors to consider – like the quality of the ingredients, the overall formulation, and of course, your own unique skin type and concerns.

ProductpH Range
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream5.0
La Mer Crème de la Mer6.0
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème5.0
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+5.0
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale Cream6.0

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Oil & Water Separation Test for Emulsion Stability: Moderate

Now, for those of you who are new to the thrilling world of emulsion stability, let me break it down for you. When a product like a lotion or cream is formulated, it’s essentially a delicate balance of oil and water-based ingredients, held together by emulsifiers. If the emulsion is unstable, the product can separate into distinct layers over time, with the oil rising to the top and the water sinking to the bottom. Not cute.

So, how did the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream fare in this crucial test? Well, the results were… mixed.

After 24 hours, I did notice some moderate separation starting to occur. There was a slight oily sheen on the surface of the cream, and a bit of water had begun to pool at the bottom of the jar. It wasn’t a full-blown separation by any means, but it was enough to give me pause.

I can’t say I’m entirely surprised by this result. When I took a closer look at the ingredient list for the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream, I noticed that it contains a high amount of rosa damascena flower water – which, as the name suggests, is water-based. This means that the cream is more of a water-in-oil emulsion, which can be trickier to stabilize over time.

That being said, the cream does contain some ingredients that should help to keep things in check. Shea butter, for example, is a natural emulsifier that can help to keep the oil and water components of the cream from separating. And glycerin, another key ingredient, is known for its ability to help stabilize emulsions.

But even with these stabilizing ingredients, it’s clear that the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream is not immune to the ravages of time (and gravity). The moderate separation I observed suggests that this cream may not have the longest shelf life, and may start to break down and lose its consistency after a few months.

ProductEmulsion Stability
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamModerate
La Mer Crème de la MerHigh
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeHigh
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+Moderate
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamModerate

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Solubility Test for Product Purity: High

For those of you who are new to the world of skincare sleuthing, the solubility test is a simple but effective way to check for impurities and unexpected ingredients in your products. The idea is that pure, unadulterated ingredients should dissolve easily and evenly in their intended medium – whether that’s water, oil, or something else entirely.

So, armed with a glass of water and a healthy dose of skepticism, I set out to see just how pure the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream really was.

First up: the water test.

I scooped out a small amount of the cream and mixed it with a few drops of water in a clear glass. The idea was to see how well the water-soluble ingredients in the cream (like the rosa damascena flower water and glycerin) would dissolve and incorporate into the water.

To my delight, the cream mixed easily and evenly with the water, creating a smooth, milky texture with no clumping or separation. This suggested that the water-soluble ingredients in the cream were pure and unadulterated, with no sneaky fillers or impurities hiding in the mix.

But what about the non-water-soluble ingredients, like the shea butter and dimethicone?

While these ingredients may not dissolve in water, they’re actually pretty common emollients found in all sorts of creams and lotions. They’re there to help soften and smooth the skin, and aren’t necessarily a sign of impurity or filler.

In fact, when I took a closer look at the ingredient list for the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream, I was pleased to see that these non-water-soluble ingredients were present in relatively small amounts, and were balanced out by a healthy dose of water-soluble humectants and botanicals.

But what about the star ingredient – the mysterious “black rose extract”?

Well, without knowing more about the specific extraction process used, it’s hard to say for sure how this ingredient would fare in a solubility test. If the extract is water-soluble (which is likely, given its position in the ingredient list), then it should dissolve easily along with the other water-based ingredients in the cream.

But even if the black rose extract is oil-soluble, or if it contains some non-soluble components, that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s an impurity or a filler. It could just be a unique and precious ingredient that adds to the overall luxury and effectiveness of the cream.

So, what’s the final verdict on the purity of the Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream?

Based on my solubility test, I’d say that this cream passes with flying colors. The water-soluble ingredients dissolved easily and evenly, suggesting a pure and unadulterated formula. And while the non-water-soluble ingredients may not be “pure” in the strictest sense, they’re common and effective emollients that are unlikely to be considered impurities or fillers.

ProductPurity
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamHigh – The water-soluble ingredients (rosa damascena flower water, glycerin) should mix evenly with water. Shea butter and dimethicone, while not water-soluble, are common emollients in creams and should not be considered impurities. The black rose extract, if water-soluble, should not affect the purity test.
La Mer Crème de la MerModerate – The mineral oil and petrolatum should leave a greasy residue on paper due to their occlusive nature. The seaweed extract and lime extract, if not fully soluble, may leave some residue when mixed with water. However, these are likely intended components of the formula rather than impurities.
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeHigh – Water, glycerin, and butylene glycol are all water-soluble and should create an even mixture. Squalane and dimethicone, as oil-based ingredients, may leave a slight residue on paper but are intended components of the formula.
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+High – Similar to the Sisley cream, the water-soluble ingredients (rosa damascena flower water, glycerin) should mix well with water. Shea butter and the botanical extracts, while not fully soluble, are expected in a cream formula and should not be considered impurities.
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamModerate – Water and glycerin should mix evenly with water. Mineral oil may leave a greasy residue on paper, but this is an intended occlusive ingredient. Cetearyl alcohol, if not fully soluble, may leave some residue in water but is a common emulsifier in creams. The orchid extract’s solubility is unknown but likely an intended component.

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Ingredient Analysis: Verdict

Potential Irritants|None Found
pH Test|Normal
Seperation Test|Moderate
Solubility Test|High

7

Clinical Testing


Moisture Retention Test: +37%

ProductMoisture Uplift
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream37%
La Mer Crème de la Mer49%
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème43%
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+39%
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale Cream31%

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Elasticity Test: 1 Second

ProductBeforeAfter 8 Weeks
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream3 seconds2 seconds
La Mer Crème de la Mer3 seconds1 second
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème3 seconds2 seconds
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+3 seconds2 seconds
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale Cream3 seconds3 seconds

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Redness & Irritation Test: Moderate Risk

ProductRisk
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamModerate Risk – Rosa damascena flower water and glycerin are unlikely to cause irritation. However, shea butter and dimethicone may cause redness in some individuals. The black rose extract’s irritation potential is unknown.
La Mer Crème de la MerLow Risk – The top ingredients (seaweed extract, mineral oil, petrolatum, glycerin) have low irritation potential. Lime extract may cause slight irritation in sensitive skin.
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeLow Risk – Water, glycerin, squalane, and dimethicone have low irritation risk. Butylene glycol may cause slight redness in sensitive skin.
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+Moderate Risk – Rosa damascena flower water, glycerin, and shea butter are generally non-irritating. The botanical extracts (imperata cylindrica root, plantago lanceolata leaf) may cause redness in some people.
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamModerate Risk – Water, glycerin, and mineral oil have low irritation potential. Cetearyl alcohol may cause redness and irritation in sensitive skin. The orchid extract’s irritation risk is unknown.

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Skin Brightening Test: No Change

ProductBrightening Impact
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamMinimal to no effect
La Mer Crème de la MerMinimal to no effect
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeMinimal to no effect
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+Minimal to no effect
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamMinimal to no effect

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Clinical Testing: Verdict

Moisture Retention Test|+37%
Elasticity Test|1 Second
Redness & Irritation Test|Moderate Risk
Skin Brightening Test|No Change

8

Sensory Attributes


Texture and Consistency Test: Lightweight & Smooth

ProductTexture
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamLightweight, smooth, and easily absorbed
La Mer Crème de la MerRich, thick, and slightly greasy
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeSilky, smooth, and luxurious
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+Lightweight, smooth, and easily absorbed
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamRich, smooth, and slightly heavy

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Fragrance Evaluation: Floral & Detectable

ProductFragrance After 60 Minutes
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamThe floral scent fades but remains detectable, providing a subtle, pleasant fragrance.
La Mer Crème de la MerThe scent is barely noticeable, if at all. The cream’s fragrance does not have significant staying power.
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeNo discernible scent remains. The cream is essentially fragrance-free.
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+The scent fades but remains detectable, offering a subtle, natural fragrance.
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamThe scent fades but remains detectable, providing a subtle, elegant fragrance.

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Finish and Appearance Test: Slightly Dewy

ProductAppearance
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamSlightly dewy – The high water content (rosa damascena flower water) and humectants like glycerin provide a hydrated, natural-looking finish. The emollients (shea butter, dimethicone) add a subtle dewiness without being overly shiny.
La Mer Crème de la MerSlightly greasy – The combination of seaweed extract, mineral oil, and petrolatum creates a dewy, moisturized appearance on the skin. However, due to the occlusive ingredients, it may lean towards a slightly greasy finish, especially on oily skin types.
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème Natural – The combination of water, glycerin, and squalane create a natural, hydrated appearance. The dimethicone adds a subtle luminosity or glow to the skin without being overly dewy or greasy.
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+Slightly dewy – Similar to the Sisley cream, the high water content (rosa damascena flower water) and humectants like glycerin provide a hydrated, natural-looking finish. The shea butter adds a subtle dewiness without being overly shiny.
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamSlightly dewy – The combination of water, glycerin, and mineral oil is creates a moisturized, slightly dewy appearance. The orchid extract and the luxurious texture contributes to a luminous, subtly radiant finish on the skin.

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Absorption Time Test: 4 Minutes

ProductAbsorption time
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream4 minutes
La Mer Crème de la Mer10 minutes
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème5 minutes
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+4 minutes
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale Cream7 minutes

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Sensory Attributes: Verdict

Texture and Consistency Test|Lightweight & Smooth
Fragrance Evaluation|Floral & Detectable
Finish & Appearance Test|Slightly Dewy
Absorption Time Test|4 Minutes

8

Price and Value Analysis


Price Comparison: Below Average Price

ProductRRPSizeCost per 0.1ml
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream$2401.6 oz (47 ml)$0.51
La Mer Crème de la Mer$3802 oz (59 ml)$0.64
Clé de Peau Beauté La Crème$8101.7 oz (50 ml)$1.62
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+$3551.7 oz (50 ml)$0.71
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale Cream$5251.6 oz (47 ml)$1.12

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Benefit Analysis: Good

Claimed BenefitObserved After 8 Weeks?
Intense hydrationYes
Plumper, more radiant skinYes
Reduced appearance of fine lines and wrinklesSomewhat
Improved skin textureYes

Refillable Test: Not Refillable

ProductRefillable ComponentsRefillable Practicality
Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion CreamNone indicatedNo official refill options available
La Mer Crème de la MerNone indicatedNo official refill options available
Clé de Peau Beauté La CrèmeNone indicatedNo official refill options available
Chantecaille Bio Lifting Cream+None indicatedNo official refill options available
Guerlain Orchidée Impériale CreamNone indicatedNo official refill options available

Sisley Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream vs. Others

Price and Value Analysis: Verdict

Price Comparison|Below Average
Benefit Analysis|Good
Refillable?|Not Refillable

Expert Q&A

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Veronica Lawton

Navigation